One Mouthy Broad

I haven't really seen much of Kreia bashing or faithful Disciple, but I think this is probably because I really haven't read that many kotor 2 stories. This is partially because the second crew of the Ebon Hawk didn't grab me as much as the first, and partially because it seems like most of them are Atton/Exile fluff pieces and I've been too lazy to go digging for better stuff. However, judging from the comments that I've seen over on the kfm boards, this doesn't surprise me at all, especially the whole trend of turning Disciple into an idiot.

Yes Disciple is somewhat naive and idealistic, but he is also a scholar and a Republic spy. He openly questions the Jedi Code and blames the rigidy of the Jedi Council for the stagnation of the Order.

Exactly. This is one of the coolest things about the Disciple, and it's too bad that people don't take this idea and run with it a bit more.

I can live with game re-tellings, hell I'm writing one so I kinda have to, but one thing that annoys me is over usage of game dialog.

Oh agreed. Like jellyjamboree, I've seen entire fics that are nothing except the game dialogue... and I don't have any idea what the author thinks that they are doing with that. As I’ve said before, the best game novelizations that I’ve seen are the ones that change things, show the scenes in between the stuff that happens in the game, and go above and beyond the actual game plot.